Listen now on Spotify and Apple Podcasts

The first wave of listeners is already chiming in. Add your voice, tap ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ on Spotify or Apple, drop a quick line, and hit follow. Let’s show the world how smart dumb thinking can be.

👋 Hey dumdums,

A friend of mine once had a bold, weird, genuinely useful idea.

She replaced her school’s late slip system with a giant bingo wheel.

Students who arrived late had to spin it and do whatever it landed on — explain their lateness as a limerick, re-enact their route using sock puppets, or confess to a fake crime (“I stole a horse to avoid algebra”).

It was creative. Disruptive. Brilliant. She did it for a senior prank. Administration shut it down by lunch.

A year later, another student resurrected the exact same wheel, but introduced it during a school-wide campaign on stress reduction.

Same bingo ball absurdity, but now it was framed as “creative consequence therapy.”

Teachers applauded it. Local press covered it. The principal called it "pedagogical whimsy at its finest."

Same idea. Same rule-breaking. The only difference was timing.

So now I wonder: is accepted originality just disobedience with good timing?

The Rule-Breaker's Paradox

In 2018, organizational researchers coined the term “creative deviance” to describe something you’ve probably done already: knowingly breaking rules to chase a good idea. The twist? That kind of deviance only turns into originality when the timing is right — specifically, when you’re under intense creative pressure AND facing heavy bureaucratic constraints.

The researchers found that breaking rules didn’t automatically boost creativity. In fact, most rule-breakers got nowhere — unless they faced two specific conditions: high-pressure problems and a tangle of bureaucratic red tape. Only then did their rebellious workarounds become truly original.

Basically: rule-breaking doesn’t help unless the rules are actually in your way and you’ve got a reason to race around them. That’s when disobedience stops being noise and starts sounding like innovation.

The Jacket They Told You Not to Buy

On Black Friday 2011, while other brands were screaming SALE, Patagonia took out a full-page ad in The New York Times that read: “Don’t Buy This Jacket.

It wasn’t a prank. It was an anti-consumerist dare. The ad listed the environmental toll of making their bestselling fleece: gallons of water used, pounds of carbon emitted, waste generated. And it urged readers, on the biggest shopping day of the year, to buy less.

Retail heresy, right? And yet… sales surged. Revenue jumped 30% the following year, and Patagonia's anti-growth stance helped catapult them to over $1 billion in annual revenue by 2017.

Critics called it virtue signaling. Fans called it integrity. Founder Yvon Chouinard just called it common sense. “The more you know, the less you need,” he said.

The Mayor Who Used Mimes

In 1995, Bogotá, Colombia elected a new mayor. That man, Antanas Mockus, was a philosopher, mathematician, and performance artist who had once dropped his pants during a lecture to make a point. He later declared war on traffic deaths using... mimes.

Actual mimes. Hundreds of them. They mocked jaywalkers and pantomimed car collisions. Combined with broader civic reforms, traffic fatalities dropped by over 50% during his first term.

His next move? He banned politicians from using bulletproof cars and swapped bureaucratic fines for "thumbs-up/thumbs-down" cards citizens could flash at each other. The city, once mired in corruption, saw a dramatic rise in civic pride and public trust.

The Economist called him “the iconoclastic mayor.” His critics called him a clown. Mockus didn’t care. He said, “Authority must be based on example, not force.”

When Street Artists Outplayed the Olympics

In 2012, as London was slathering itself in Olympic sponsors, a rogue art collective called Brandalism hijacked over 30 corporate billboards across the UK. Instead of iPhones or fizzy drinks, commuters saw twisted parodies: a car ad rebranded as a death trap, a soda ad reimagined as planetary doom.

It was illegal. It was beautiful. And the timing? Perfect. At the peak of Olympic brand overload, these artists surgically hacked into the corporate bloodstream.

The press went berserk. Public debate lit up about ad creep and who controls public space. And just like that, Brandalism wasn’t a prank — it became a movement. They’ve since pulled similar stunts at COP21 and during Australia’s bushfire crisis, swapping hundreds of paid ads for subversive art.

One agency executive sneered, “It’s vandalism, not critique.”

Pronounced: (par-RAY-zee-uh)

Dumb Word of the Day: “Parrhesia”

Parrhesia — radical honesty that breaks the rules of politeness, power, or protocol.

Straight outta ancient Greece and into your inbox, parrhesia is what happens when someone speaks uncomfortable truth at exactly the wrong (ahem, right) moment. Think: Patagonia’s “Don’t Buy This Jacket” ad, or Brandalism’s billboard-hacks in the shadow of Olympic brand mania. It's not just truth-telling — it’s timed defiance with a bullhorn.

Use it in a sentence: “I opened the board meeting by saying our mission statement is word salad. Total parrhesia — but it worked.”

(should you choose to accept it)

Disobey on Purpose Challenge

This week, try a Micro-Parrhesia move:

  1. Identify a small rule or norm you secretly think is bogus — something everyone follows, but you know is hollow, performative, or outdated.

  2. Break it — deliberately, gently, and at a moment when it's just wrong enough to be right.

  3. Watch what happens. Did it spark a better conversation? Get a laugh? Shift the energy?

Example: I once signed off a client email with “Respectfully disobeying, Yours in chaos.” Not only did it spark a real conversation about the absurdity of our process, we ended up rewriting the whole brief—better, faster, and with 40% fewer jargon grenades.

Your goal: don't be rude — be well-timed weird.

🎤 YOUR TURN

So... where did your most unhinged coddiwomple take you?

Hit reply and spill it. I’ll toss every response into my very official, moderately haunted Hat of Chance™, and one lucky drifter will receive a souvenir jar of Plot Twist Preserves. (Flavor unknown. Possibly legal. Definitely weird.)

Until next time. Your devoted detourist,
David 🛵💭

Dumbify: Dumb Ideas, Delivered Weekly (You’re Welcome).

How did you like today's newsletter?

Login or Subscribe to participate

More from the Dumbiverse:

Reply

or to participate

Keep Reading

No posts found