
Listen now on Spotify and Apple Podcasts
👋 Hey dumdums,
We’ve talked about intuition — your brain whispering, “something’s off.”
Then imagination — your brain throwing spaghetti at the future to see what sticks.
Then emotion — your body yelling, “this one matters!”
And now, the one that ties it all together…
How to pick which imagined, heart-fueled, half-brilliant idea actually deserves to live.
A few nights ago, I was staring at my biggest idea yet. It felt electric. It also felt… slightly deranged.
Then this quiet voice chimed in, not fear, not logic, just a tiny, polite cough from somewhere near the back of my skull:
“Maybe test this before going full send mode.”
That’s commonsense — the fourth pillar of Angus Fletcher’s ‘Primal Intelligence.’
It’s the faculty that asks if your genius idea can survive contact with the actual world. The one full of bills, opinions, and gravity.
What Do We Mean by "Commonsense"

The word “commonsense” sounds like something your uncle says before explaining why he doesn’t believe in hybrid cars. But Fletcher's version is different.
He defines commonsense as the ability to match the newness of your actions to the newness of the situation (your built-in weirdness detector meets your reality thermometer).
It’s how you know which wild idea might actually work, and which will end with you Googling “can you return a llama?”
Commonsense isn’t logic. AI’s got logic covered.
It’s contextual, narrative, and deeply human. It’s the ability to feel what fits.
It’s what lets you predict that, yes, moving your knight there might technically win the chess game but will emotionally ruin Thanksgiving.
And here’s the depressing part… we’re losing it.
Schools reward rule-following, algorithms reward conformity, and we’ve slowly outsourced our judgment to anything with a loading bar.
Meanwhile, commonsense, this subtle, story-shaped ability to sense what will actually work in the real world, is quietly atrophying.
The irony is it’s the one thing computers will never be able to replicate.
Because…
Commonsense isn’t code. It’s lived experience stitched together with intuition, imagination, and emotion.
It doesn’t kill creativity. It protects it.
It’s the friend who doesn’t say, “That’s stupid.”
It says, “Okay, but maybe don’t announce it on LinkedIn yet.”
How It Works (A Dumb-Science-Inspired Model)

Here’s my best attempt at reverse-engineering how commonsense actually works:
Intuition spots something weird.
The spark. The hunch. The “something’s off.”Imagination explodes with possibilities.
Your brain turns into a late-night focus group of terrible and brilliant ideas.Emotion highlights the ones that matter.
Suddenly, you care.Then commonsense shows up with its clipboard in hand.
It starts asking annoying but important questions like:How messy is this, really?
What’s the terrain?
How many people will I need to convince, bribe, or disappoint?
Next comes the “movie test.”
Commonsense plays your idea like a full-length film, including the boring middle part where you’re tired, broke, and your laptop crashes mid-pitch.
Does your story still hold up, or does the protagonist (you) end up weeping in a Target parking lot by Act Two?Then comes the sensibility filter.
Can this plan survive gravity, other humans, and your own attention span?
Not the fantasy version of you. The real one who forgets passwords and resents meetings.Finally there’s the selection.
Commonsense trims the list. It doesn’t mourn the lost ideas. It thanks them for their service.
Commonsense is editing. It’s imagination’s proofreader, red pen in hand, muttering, “Cute subplot. Cut it.”
Why Commonsense Matters

“Commonsense” sounds dull next to the glam trio of intuition, imagination, and emotion.
Those three are the band. Commonsense is the tour manager making sure they don’t die in a Motel 6.
But here’s why Fletcher thinks it’s indispensable:
It keeps your good ideas from killing you.
You can dream big. You just shouldn’t do it while ignoring physics, sleep, or taxes.It builds trust between dreaming and doing.
Commonsense is the handshake between vision and execution. It says, “Let’s see if this works outside the group chat.”It’s the one thing AI can’t fake.
Machines can generate infinite options.
Only humans can tell which ones pass the “will this actually function among other flawed humans?” test.It’s the closer of the quartet.
Intuition spots.
Imagination expands.
Emotion signals.
Commonsense decides.
Without it, the first three pillars are a psychedelic screensaver.
With it, they’re a plan.

Dumb Word of the Day: Paracosm
(PAIR-uh-coz-um) — a vivid imaginary world, the kind of detailed fantasy land you build in your head and visit regularly.
Your imagination builds paracosms. Elaborate ones. Paracosms where you're a bestselling novelist, or you've quit your job to run a pottery studio, or you've moved to Portugal and learned to surf at 42.
Commonsense is the friend who visits these paracosms, tosses rocks at the drawbridge, tests whether the plumbing works, and gently points out that you get motion-sick on boats, so maybe the houseboat idea needs a revision.
Let's use it in a sentence:
"I built an entire paracosm where I'd host elegant dinner parties with hand-lettered place cards and seven-course meals. Commonsense reminded me that last Tuesday I served nachos directly on my coffee table and called it 'rustic.'"
The Commonsense Challenge
Take one of those imaginative futures you've been noodling on from earlier newsletters. (You know the one. It's probably been sitting in your Notes app for three weeks with a vague emoji next to it.)
Now do this:
Sketch it out. Bullet the key arcs, needs, and risks. What has to happen for this to work? What has to keep happening?
Imagine injecting it into real life. Not the sanitized version of your life, but the actual one. The one with the leaky faucet and the friend who always cancels plans and your tendency to order takeout when you're tired. What breaks first? What friction quietly murders your plan while you're not looking?
Ask which parts actually survive. Not which parts you wish would survive. Which parts hold up under contact with reality's general absurdity?
Design a minimal pilot. A micro-experiment that tests one core assumption. Not the whole grand vision, just the smallest hinge the whole thing swings on.
Don't wait for perfect conditions. Test what feels plausible. And let commonsense be your guide.
🎁 Final Takeaway
You’ve got the full set now:
Intuition — the spark.
Imagination — the expansion.
Emotion — the signal.
Commonsense — the selector.
Together they make up your Primal Intelligence. The messy, narrative-driven operating system no AI can mimic, because it runs on meaning, context, and chaos.
Commonsense is the bridge between genius and oops. It’s what turns “I could do that” into “I’m actually doing that.”
So go ahead, spot the oddity, spin the futures, feel what hums, and then let commonsense test-drive the one worth building.
Because the world doesn’t need another perfect idea.
It needs a plausible one.
David 🎉
Dumbify: Dumb Ideas, Delivered Weekly (You’re Welcome).





